You can throw me in the Colbert County jailhouse.
You can throw me off the Wilson Dam
but there ain’t much difference in the man I wanna be and the man I really am.
We ain’t never gonna change.
“The Dirty South” was released on August 24 in 2004 – 12 years ago today.
The Dirty South is the fifth album by Alabamian alternative country/Southern rock group Drive-By Truckers, released in 2004. The Dirty South is Drive-By Truckers’ third concept album. Like its two predecessors, the album examines the state of the South, and unveils the hypocrisy, irony, and tragedy that continues to exist.
- “Where the Devil Don’t Stay” (Cooley)
- “Tornadoes” (Hood)
- “The Day John Henry Died” (Isbell)
- “Puttin’ People on the Moon” (Hood)
- “Carl Perkins’ Cadillac” (Cooley)
- “The Sands of Iwo Jima” (Hood)
- “Danko/Manuel” (Isbell)
- “The Boys from Alabama” (Hood)
- “Cottonseed” (Cooley)
- “The Buford Stick” (Hood)
- “Daddy’s Cup” (Cooley)
- “Never Gonna Change” (Isbell)
- “Lookout Mountain” (Hood)
- “Goddamn Lonely Love” (Isbell)
- “Where The Devil Don’t Stay” was inspired by a poem by Mike Cooley’s uncle Ed Cooley, and was recorded in one take.
- Patterson Hood’s “Tornadoes” was originally written in 1988 in reaction to the closing concert for the Adam’s House Cat Nightmare Tour. The Nightmare Tour set list was composed almost exclusively of songs containing metaphors or imagery of trains, but the lack of the tour’s success forced Hood and his band to abandon the concept and start afresh. Hood read an eyewitness account of the tornado in the local paper the next day and wrote “Tornadoes” after reading her statement that “it sounded like a train.”
- Isbell’s “The Day John Henry Died”, retells the story of John Henry.
- “Puttin’ People on the Moon”, written by Hood, tells the story of a town downriver of Huntsville and their “rocket envy” or economic depression due to the negative environmental and economic effects of NASA’s Marshall Space Flight Center.
- Mike Cooley’s “Carl Perkins’ Cadillac” recounts the celebrated Sun Records, Sam Phillips, and the music industry in general.
- “The Sands of Iwo Jima” recounts Hood’s experiences with his great uncle while growing up in North Alabama. Questioning the veracity of the movie, his uncle answers ironically that John Wayne was never there at the time.
- Isbell’s second track on the album, “Danko/Manuel”, is a departure from the usual southern gothic lyrical style written by Cooley and Hood. Originally Isbell tried to tell the story of Rick Danko, Richard Manuel, and The Band’s demise, but found the scope of the concept too difficult to actually do justice to their story, and instead shifted the concept to a telling of life of a musician through the eyes and actions of Danko and Manuel. Isbell stated that the horn parts for the song came to him in a dream.
- “The Boys From Alabama” was inspired by the misconceptions and “really bad movies” of the Redneck Mafia and recounts the movie Walking Tall from a “different point of view”. Hood felt that telling the story from “the bad guy’s” point of view would be more interesting.
- Cooley’s “Cottonseed” tells a story of corruption, crime, killing, greed, fixed elections, guns, drugs, prostitution and alcohol and uses subtle imagery to provide a very negative interpretation of Pusser.
- Hood’s “The Buford Stick” completes the suite by providing examples of the negative effects of Pusser’s actions while offering a less glorified view of the mythology surrounding Pusser.
- Cooley’s last song on the album is a story about a father who instills a love of racing in his son. Interestingly, “Daddy’s Cup” is the only song on The Dirty South that does not revolve around a negative experience, instead offering a lighter touch to the overall ‘dirty’ feel of the album.
- Isbell has explained that “Never Gonna Change” is simply about a stubborn North Alabama man who “refuses to live in fear,” which Isbell goes on to explain are rather rare.
- “Lookout Mountain” was written around 1990 by Hood, and can be heard in its original incarnation on Adam’s House Cat’s LP Town Burned Down. It was a last minute addition to the album, beating out another Hood song entitled “Goode’s Field Road.” …. The version as it appears on The Dirty South was recorded in one take.
- The Dirty South ends with Isbell’s “Goddamn Lonely Love.” Though described by Isbell as a love song, “Goddamn Lonely Love” heavily and painfully delves into the loneliness associated with love. Isbell wrote the song for Shonna Tucker.
As of February 2008, The Dirty South is Drive-By Truckers’ best-selling album.
The Dirty South was recorded at FAME Studios in Muscle Shoals, Alabama.
- Mike Cooley – guitar, vocals
- Patterson Hood – guitar, vocals
- Jason Isbell – guitar, vocals
- Brad Morgan – drums
- Shonna Tucker – bass
Here is an incredible Drive-By Truckers concert from the summer of 2004 (fantastic sound and a great set list, a must download!):
Download link (via Archive.org)
From allmusic.com (Mark Deming):
When you’ve named your band the Drive-By Truckers and your first three albums are called Pizza Deliverance, Gangstabilly, and Alabama Ass Whuppin’, you might have a hard time at first convincing folks that you aren’t joking. But the Drive-By Truckers proved that they were most definitely not kidding with 2001’s brilliant double-disc Southern Rock Opera, and 2003’s Decoration Day actually upped the ante on what might have been a fluke masterpiece with its dark and thoroughly absorbing chronicle of hard times in the American South. With The Dirty South, the DBTs have crafted an equally effective companion piece to Decoration Day that plays on the gangsta rap reference of its title with a set of vividly rendered portraits of life along the margins of respectability below the Mason-Dixon line, from laid-off factory rats dealing drugs to feed their kids to Alabama gangsters determined to shut down the cops who made their daughters cry. From the first low, metallic stomps from Brad Morgan’s kick drum on “Where the Devil Don’t Stay,” it’s clear that The Dirty South isn’t going to be a good-time party most of the way, and while there are some brilliant anthemic rockers on this album (most notably “The Day John Henry Died,” “Carl Perkins’ Cadillac,” and “Never Gonna Change”), and…
Read more @ allmusic.com
Robert Christgau writes:
Class warfare meets gangsta-rock. The imagistic density of the songs about working for a living till you die–especially Jason Isbell’s poetic “The Day John Henry Died” and Patterson Hood’s narrative “Puttin’ People on the Moon”–makes the vicious cycle seem more inescapable; their class consciousness justifies the badass nihilism of the anti-Buford Pusser triptych like ghetto sob stories about dope lords’ pain do, only without the sentimentality. Then there are the two about successful musicians. Sam Phillips was OK for a rich man, but he could only take Carl Perkins so far. And Rick Danko ends up not much better off alive than Richard Manuel is dead. A-
It’s not just self-aware regionalism or Southern-by-the-grace-of-God cockiness, but something deeper: On these 14 songs, the Drive-By Truckers find the connections between these larger-than-life figures and the life-size experiences that shaped them. For them, the South is a stretch of highway where many have died, an ordinary place made extraordinary by human tragedies. The Dirty South is their homemade roadside memorial.
– Stephen M. Deusner (Pitchfork)
Never Gonna Change:
The Boys From Alabama:
Goddamn Lonely Love:
The Dirty South on Spotify:
Some related prev posts:
- Great song: Carl Perkins’ Cadillac
- Video of the day: God damn lonely love – Jason Isbell
- Video of the day: 18 wheels of love – The Drive-by Truckers
- Great song: “The Three Great Alabama Icons” – Drive-by Truckers
-Egil and Hallgeir